By Yanis Varoufakis - Project Syndicate | March 6, 2025
If we truly want to strengthen Europe, the first step is not to rearm. It is to forge the democratic union without which stagnation will continue to erode Europe’s capacities, rendering it unable to rebuild what is left of Ukraine once Vladimir Putin is finished with it.
ATHENS – Inducting Ukraine into NATO after forcing Russia back behind its pre-2014 borders has been the only strategic aim EU leaders have allowed themselves to contemplate since Russia’s invasion three years ago. Alas, well before US President Donald Trump’s re-election, this aim slipped into the realm of infeasibility. The writing had been on the wall for a while.
First, Russian President Vladimir Putin’s war economy proved a godsend to his regime. Second, even Trump’s predecessor, Joe Biden, was terminally unwilling to push for Ukraine’s NATO membership, leading the country down the garden path with vague promises. And, third, there was strong bipartisan opposition in the United States to the idea of NATO troops fighting alongside Ukrainians.
So, in a display of breathtaking hypocrisy, the many “Putin is the new Hitler” speeches never resulted in a commitment to fight alongside the Ukrainians until Putin’s army was defeated on the ground. Instead, a cowardly West kept sending weapons to the exhausted Ukrainians so that they could defeat the “new Hitler” on its behalf – but on their own.
Inevitably, and despite gallant fighting by increasingly outgunned and outnumbered Ukrainian soldiers, European leaders’ sole strategic aim turned to dust – a reality that would have become undeniable regardless of who won the US presidency last November. Trump merely brought it forward with a brutality reflecting his long-held contempt not just for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky but also for the EU itself. And so, lacking any Plan B, a Europe weakened by a two-decades-long economic slump is now struggling to respond to Trump’s Ukraine policy.
After the Munich Agreement in 1938, Winston Churchill famously proclaimed that Neville Chamberlain had been “given the choice between war and dishonor. You chose dishonor, and you will have war.” In their angst not to make the same mistake, EU leaders are about to repeat it, in reverse: their war-until-victory approach will give way to the humiliating peace that Trump will gleefully impose on them, and on Zelensky’s government, when they eventually come begging.
While it is undoubtedly true that Europe must either rise to the occasion or disintegrate, the question is: Rise how? What’s really wrong with Europe? What is the EU missing the most?
It beggars belief that Europeans cannot recognize the answer staring us in the face: Europe is missing a proper Treasury, the equivalent of the State Department, and a Parliament with the power to dismiss what passes as its government (the European Council). Even worse, there is still no discussion of how to plug these gaping holes in Europe’s institutional architecture.
The EU has always dreaded the beginning of any Ukraine peace process precisely because it would expose the bloc’s nakedness. Who would represent Europe at the negotiating table, even if Trump invited us to join? Even if the European Commission and Council could wave a magic wand to conjure a large, well-armed EU army into existence, who would have the democratic authority to send it into battle to kill and be killed?
Moreover, who can raise enough taxes to ensure the EU army’s permanent combat-readiness? The EU’s intergovernmental decision-making means that no one has the democratic legitimacy to make such decisions.
When Ursula von der Leyen, the President of the European Commission, recently announced her new ReArm Europe initiative, sad memories of the incompetent Juncker Plan, Green Deal, and Recovery Plan came flooding back. Large headline figures were again being tossed about, only to be exposed on closer scrutiny as smoke and mirrors. Does anyone seriously expect France to increase its already-unsustainable public-finance deficit to fund weaponry?
Absent the institutions to enact military Keynesianism, the only way Europe can rearm is by shifting funds from its crumbling social and physical infrastructure – further weakening a Europe already reaping the bitter harvest of popular discontent, which is fueling the rise of far-right forces across the continent. And for what? Does anyone believe that Putin will be deterred by a Europe that may have a few more shells and howitzers but is drifting further away from the prospect of the federal governance needed to decide matters of war and peace?
ReArm Europe will do nothing to win the war for Ukraine. It will, however, almost certainly drive the EU deeper into its pre-existing economic slump – the underlying cause of Europe’s weakness. To keep Europeans safe in the face of the twin challenges posed by Trump and Putin, the EU must embark on its own multipronged Peace Now process.
First, the EU must reject outright Trump’s predatory effort to grab Ukraine’s natural resources. Then, after floating the prospect of relaxing sanctions and returning $300 billion in frozen assets (which cannot simultaneously be used as a bargaining chip and for Ukraine’s reconstruction), the EU should commence negotiations with the Kremlin, offering the prospect of a comprehensive strategic arrangement within which Ukraine becomes what Austria was during the Cold War: sovereign, armed, neutral, and as integrated with Western Europe as its citizens desire.
Third, instead of a permanent stand-off between two large armies along the agreed border, the EU should propose a demilitarized zone at least 500 kilometers (310 miles) deep on each side, the right of return of all displaced people, a Good Friday-style agreement for the governance of disputed areas, and a Green New Deal for the war-torn areas, jointly financed by the EU and Russia. All outstanding issues should be addressed in negotiations held under the auspices of the United Nations.
Lastly, the EU should use the prospect of relaxing tariffs on Chinese goods (green tech, in particular) and sanctions on technology exports to open negotiations with China with a view to a new security arrangement that reduces tensions and enlists the Chinese to the goal of safeguarding Ukraine’s sovereignty.
If we truly want to strengthen Europe, the first step is not to rearm. It is to forge the democratic union without which stagnation will continue to erode Europe’s capacities, rendering it unable to rebuild what is left of Ukraine once Putin is finished with it.
Yanis Varoufakis, a former finance minister of Greece, is leader of the MERA25 party and Professor of Economics at the University of Athens.
Copyright Project Syndicate
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. EU Leaders To Discuss €800bn Rearmament Plan - TIPP Insights
EU leaders are meeting in Brussels for a special summit to discuss proposals to mobilize up to €800 billion for Europe’s rearmament and to offer "immediate" military support to Ukraine following Washington's aid suspension.
2. European Air Force Could Halt Russian Attacks On Ukraine - TIPP Insights
A new plan drawn up by military experts suggests that a European air force of 120 fighter jets operated separately from NATO could secure the skies from Russian attacks without provoking a wider conflict with Moscow.
3. Kremlin Says Rubio's View Of Ukraine Conflict As A US-Russia Proxy War Matches That Of Putin - Reuters
The Kremlin said on Thursday that U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio's view that the Ukraine conflict is a proxy war between the United States and Russia is in line with Russian President Vladimir Putin's own assessment.
"It's been very clear from the beginning that (U.S. President Donald Trump) views this as a protracted, stalemated conflict," Rubio told Fox News in an interview on Wednesday."
And frankly, it's a proxy war between nuclear powers – the United States, helping Ukraine, and Russia – and it needs to come to an end."
4. France Offering Intelligence To Ukraine Amid Washington Suspension - Reuters
France is offering intelligence to Ukraine, Defense Minister Sebastien Lecornu said, a day after Washington said it was suspending intelligence sharing with Kyiv, an effort to step up pressure on Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
“We have intelligence resources that we use to help the Ukrainians,” Lecornu told radio station France Inter. Lecornu also said France’s nuclear weapons stockpile, developed in the early days of the Cold War and designed to be independent from the then-dominant powers Washington and Moscow, was sufficient.
5. Putin Appoints Alexander Darchiyev As Russia’s New Ambassador To Washington - Reuters
Russian Foreign Ministry said last week Washington had given it the green light to appoint Darchiyev at a meeting between Russian and U.S. officials in Turkey.
Darchiyev is a career diplomat who has served two long spells in Russia’s Washington embassy and was ambassador to Canada from 2014 to 2021. He is currently head of the Foreign Ministry’s North America Department.
6. China Files Revised Dispute Consultations Request With U.S. On Tariff Measures, WTO Says - Reuters
China's revised request comes after an extra 10% duty on Chinese goods took effect Tuesday, adding to the 10% tariff imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump on February 4.
Bilateral consultations are the first stage of formal dispute settlement. If within 60 days no solution is found, China could request adjudication by the Geneva-based organisation's dispute settlement body. Canada also requested WTO consultations with the United States on "unjustified tariffs".
7. China’s Crackdown On Dissent: Over 1,500 Convicted In Six Years, Report Finds - RFA
Chinese authorities have arbitrarily detained thousands of people for peacefully defending or exercising their rights over the past six years and convicted 1,545 prisoners of conscience, a rights group said.
Chinese Human Rights Defenders, or CHRD, a non-government organization of domestic and overseas Chinese rights activists, said the scope and scale of wrongful detention by Chinese authorities may constitute crimes against humanity.
8. Hamas Says Trump Threats Are Support For Netanyahu To Back Out Of Gaza Ceasefire Deal - Reuters
Hamas said that President Trump’s repeated threats against Palestinians constituted support for Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to back out of the Gaza ceasefire and intensify the siege of Gazans.
In a text message to Reuters, Hamas spokesperson Abdel-Latif al-Qanoua said: “The best track to release the remaining Israeli prisoners is by the occupation going into the second phase and compelling it to adhere to the agreement signed under the sponsorship of mediators.”
9. Panama President Calls Trump's Talk Of 'Reclaiming' The Panama Canal A Lie - A.P.
Panama President José Raúl Mulino accused President Donald Trump of lying when he said in his address to Congress that his administration was “reclaiming” the Panama Canal.
Panama maintains that it has full control over the canal, that the Hong Kong-based group's operation of the ports did not amount to Chinese control over the waterway, and that, therefore, the sale to a U.S.-based company would not represent any U.S. “reclaiming” of the canal. Panama's government called the sale a private transaction.
10. NZ Fires Envoy To UK Who Questioned Trump's Grasp Of History - BBC
At an event in London on Tuesday, High Commissioner to the UK Phil Goff compared efforts to end the war between Russia and Ukraine to the Munich Agreement of 1938, which allowed Adolf Hitler to annex Czechoslovakia.
Goff recalled how Sir Winston Churchill had criticised the agreement, then said of the U.S. leader: "President Trump has restored the bust of Churchill to the Oval Office. But do you think he really understands history?"
New Zealand's Foreign Minister Winston Peters said Goff's comments were "deeply disappointing" and made his position "untenable."
11. Iranian Musician Flogged 74 Times Over Protest Song In Support Of Women's Rights - UPI
Iranian musician Mehdi Yarrahi received 74 lashes as part of his sentence a song supporting women's rights and opposes the Middle Eastern country's draconian hijab laws, his lawyer said.
Yarrahi, a singer-songwriter known for his protest music, was arrested in late August 2023 and sentenced to two years and eight months in prison, with one year enforceable, along with a fine and 74 lashes. Yarrahi was arrested following the release of his song, "Roo Sarito," which translates to "Your Headscarf" in English.
12. Greenland PM On Trump's U.S. Annexation Idea: No Thanks - UPI
Greenland Prime Minister Mute Egede said the people of Greenland will determine their future and don't want to be part of the United States or Denmark.
"We do not want to be Americans nor Danes. We are Kalaallit," Egede said in a Facebook post that is written in Greenland's native language.
Trump said Greenland becoming a U.S. territory would make Greenland's population safe and rich. Egede in his Facebook response said it's important for "Americans and their leader" to understand the people of Greenland want to be independent.
13. North Korea Suspends Foreign Tours To Rason, Less Than A Month After Resumption - RFA
North Korea has closed its only gateway for foreign tourists, travel companies said, weeks after allowing visitors back in, which had suggested it was opening up for the first time since imposing a COVID-19 ban on arrivals in 2020.
North Korea opened its special tourist city of Rason, on its northern coast near the borders with both China and Russia, to foreign tour groups in mid-February. But two travel agencies said arrivals had been suspended. Some South Korean media outlets speculated that the decision was driven by concerns over the uncontrolled spread of information.
14. El Salvador Announces More Bitcoin Purchases, Gives IMF Assurances - Reuters
El Salvador announced the purchase of bitcoin, which takes the total in the country's strategic reserve to above 6,102 coins, the National Bitcoin Office posted on social media.
The bitcoin purchase announcement comes days after the International Monetary Fund board approved a 40-month program with El Salvador for $1.4 billion that implied a downgrade of the cryptocurrency's status in the Central American country. Bitcoin cannot be used to pay taxes and its acceptance by the public is voluntary, which is not what was expected when it was given a legal tender status back in 2021. Importantly, the government has committed to the IMF not to accumulate further bitcoins "at the level of the overall public sector" according to the IMF.
15. If You're Thinking About Selling Your Stocks, You Might Want To Think Twice - AP
Much like all the upheaval shaking the world, the huge swings rocking Wall Street may feel far from normal. But, for investing at least, all this is typical.
Sharp moves for the U.S. stock market, like its recent 6% drop in just a couple of weeks, happen regularly. Stomaching them is the price investors have to pay for the bigger returns that stocks can offer over other investments in the long term.
16. Surgery Just Before The Weekend A Bad Idea, Study Suggests - HealthDay News
People who undergo surgery just before the weekend have a significantly increased risk of death and complications, researchers reported in JAMA Network Open.
Hospitals and health care systems tend to operate with skeleton crews during the weekend, leading to concerns that patients are more likely to receive worse care on Saturday and Sunday, researchers said in background notes. This is commonly called the "weekend effect." This "weekend effect" occurred across 25 common procedures representing multiple surgical specialties, researchers said.
16. Gallup: Over 30M Americans Borrowed Roughly $74B For Medical Bills In 2024 - UPI
A new Gallup survey has suggested that 12% of American adults, or about 31 million people, were forced to borrow tens of billions of dollars in the past year to pay for personal medical bills.
The findings released was a joint partnership with West Health, a family of nonprofit and nonpartisan organizations centered on aging and healthcare. It found that women, Black, Hispanic and young adults were more likely to borrow for health expenses, the survey says. It added that some 58% of the American public share concern over medical debt if faced with a medical emergency.
