By Bartosz M. Rydliński - Project Syndicate | Feb 24, 2025
Fear of being left behind economically and socially proved to be potent fuel for the far-right Alternative für Deutschland, which for the first time won more votes than the Social Democrats in a German federal election. So long as center-left parties fail to address this fear, the far right will continue to exploit it.
WARSAW – Germany’s Social Democrats are one of the West’s oldest political parties, with a legacy of advocating parliamentary democracy, opposing Nazism, and leading the modernization of postwar Germany. In addition to the many notable labor, economic, and human-rights reforms that the party has implemented over the years, former SPD leader and West German Chancellor Willy Brandt’s Ostpolitik in the 1970s laid the groundwork for Germany’s reunification in 1990.
But today’s SPD is a shadow of its former self: the party won only 16.4% of the vote in Sunday’s federal election, putting it behind both the Christian Democratic Union/Christian Social Union (CDU/CSU) and the far-right Alternative für Deutschland (AfD). It is worth considering how this defeat came about, and what it means for the future of Western social-democratic forces.
Support for the SPD began to fall toward the end of the 2000s. In the 2005 and 2009 federal elections, the party received, respectively, 34.2% and 23% of the vote – a drastic decline from the 1998 federal election, when it won nearly 41% of the vote. This drop-off can be largely attributed to the Agenda 2010 and Hartz reforms that Chancellor Gerhard Schröder introduced in the early 2000s. Schröder’s neoliberal project, which sought to revive a stagnant German economy by deregulating the labor market and reducing welfare benefits, put the SPD at odds with its working-class base, organized in powerful trade unions. It also led the charismatic finance minister and former party leader Oskar Lafontaine to defect to a left-wing alliance, taking the SPD’s socialist faction with him.
Despite this exodus of voters, the SPD could rest on its laurels as the junior coalition partner to the CDU/CSU – its main competitor – under Germany’s “Iron Chancellor,” Angela Merkel. When Merkel retired in 2021, the SPD won that year’s election with one-quarter of German votes. But SPD leader and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz had to form a “traffic-light coalition” (so named for the parties’ colors), with the Greens and the liberal, market-oriented Free Democrats. This led his government to pursue conflicting goals: advancing social justice and lowering taxes; constructing social housing and boosting support for entrepreneurs; combating climate change and protecting Germany’s automotive industry. Such a wide-ranging agenda did little to win back the trust of workers, especially with fear of globalization on the rise.
In the lead-up to the recent election, neither Scholz nor his party seemed to gauge German voters’ primary concerns accurately. According to Infratest dimap’s ARD-DeutschlandTREND survey, 37% of Germans consider immigration to be the most important problem facing the country – an issue on which the SPD has been ambivalent and indecisive. The party tacitly supported Merkel’s “open-door policy” in 2015, when Germany accepted more than one million asylum-seekers from Syria, Afghanistan, and other countries in the Middle East and North Africa. And yet, Scholz has advocated deporting “serious criminals” to Syria and Afghanistan following terror attacks. Instead of winning over voters, this muddled approach to migration and security has bolstered the anti-immigration AfD’s claim that it was right all along about the “Muslim threat.”
The second most important issue for voters, according to the Infratest dimap survey, is the economy, with 34% of respondents agreeing that it should be the government’s top priority. As an article about Scholz in Der Spiegel recently pointed out, the German economy contracted for the second consecutive year in 2024, the number of unemployed people is rising, industry is cutting jobs, and consumer confidence has tanked. The fact that this occurred on Scholz’s watch undermined his image as a successful economic steward, burnished during Merkel’s term. This resulted in a devastating loss of working-class support for the SPD. According to Infratest dimap’s exit poll, the AfD won 38% of workers’ votes, compared to just 12% for the SPD.
Scholz fell short in other areas, too. The much-heralded turning point (Zeitenwende) in foreign policy and national security after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 has not materialized. Germany barely met NATO’s 2% defense-spending target and has not honored its commitments to Ukraine. As Benjamin Tallis concluded in his report titled “The End of the Zeitenwende” for the German Council on Foreign Relations, Scholz’s project has been a failure.
The SPD’s electoral disaster is reminiscent of the Democrats’ defeat in the 2024 US presidential election. Both parties failed to formulate an effective response to migration concerns, win over working-class voters, and adopt major progressive economic reforms. Instead, they chose to emphasize cultural liberalism, which appealed to the winners of globalization – people who do not fear for their future.
But fear of being left behind economically and socially proved to be potent fuel for both Donald Trump and the AfD. So long as social democrats fail to address this fear, the far right will continue to exploit it. If center-left parties want to regain their relevance, they must confront and analyze their electoral failures and declining support while finding new ways to make inroads with workers and shield them from the effects of deindustrialization, automation, and artificial intelligence.
Bartosz M. Rydliński is an assistant professor in political science at Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw.
Copyright Project Syndicate
Related Articles
Germany’s Last-Chance Election—Michael Bröning, Project Syndicate
Germany At A Crossroads—Ulrike Malmendier , Thilo Kroeger, and Christopher Zuber, Project Syndiacate
The Berlin Reckoning—Editorial Board, TIPP Insights
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. Huge Crowds Attend Funeral For Slain Hezbollah Leader Seyyed Hassan Nasrallah - UPI
Large numbers of Hezbollah followers flocked to Beirut's largest sports stadium on Sunday to attend a mass funeral of their slain leader Seyyed Hassan Nasrallah, nearly five months after he was assassinated in an Israeli strike.
Nasrallah’s official funeral was delayed because of then Israel's intensified air strikes and until it withdraws its forces in line with a Nov. 27 cease-fire agreement that was brokered by the U.S. and France to end 14 months of a devastating war between the two enemies.
2. Ukraine: Zelenskyy offers to quit in return for NATO entry - D.W.
"If there is peace for Ukraine, if you really need me to leave my post, I am ready. ... I can exchange it for NATO," President Volodymyr Zelenskyy told a press conference in Kyiv.
During the press conference, the Ukrainian leader called on Trump to provide concrete security guarantees to help Kyiv defend itself. Zelenskyy also said he wanted to see U.S. President Donald Trump as a partner to Ukraine and more than simply a mediator between Kyiv and Moscow.
3. Trump-Putin Summit Preparations Are Underway, Russia Says - A.P.
Speaking to Russian state media, Russia’s deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov said a possible Putin-Trump summit could involve broad talks on global issues, not just the war in Ukraine.
He said efforts to organize such a meeting are at an early stage, and that making it happen will require “the most intensive preparatory work.” Ryabkov added that U.S. and Russian envoys could meet within the next two weeks to pave the way for further talks among senior officials.
4. North Korea Expected To Send Many Health Workers To Russia: Think Tank - RFA
North Korea is expected to send a large number of healthcare workers to Russia for training, a South Korean government-backed think tank said, as it tries to address a lack of in-house capabilities to achieve a goal of modernizing rural health services.
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un pledged in early February to make the modernization of regional health services a “top priority,” highlighting the “wide gap” between urban and rural areas. Jeong Eun-mi, a researcher at the Korean Institute for National Unification, believes the North will have no choice but to rely on Russia as it lacks the capability to achieve those aims on its own.
5. China Accuses Australia Of 'Hyping' Live-Fire Navy Drills - D.W.
China's Defense Ministry said that Canberra had made "unreasonable accusations" and deliberately "hyped up" the situation after three flights were diverted because of Beijing's live-fire drills.
On Saturday, China, for the second consecutive day, conducted live-fire naval drills in international waters between Australia and New Zealand, which led to disruptions in flights. Australian Defense Minister Richard Marles said that while China did not violate international law, it did not follow the best practice of giving 12-24 hours' notice, and Canberra had raised this issue with Beijing.
6. Japan, Philippines OK Strategic Talks Between Forces Amid China Rise - Kyodo News
Japanese Defense Minister Gen Nakatani and his Philippine counterpart Gilberto Teodoro agreed to establish a strategic dialogue between Japan's Self-Defense Forces and the Philippine military, amid security challenges posed by China.
Security ties between Japan and the Philippines, both close U.S. allies, have deepened in recent years amid China's increasing military activities and territorial claims in regional waters. The two also agreed to deepen ties with countries including the United States and Australia.
7. Vietnam Outpaces Malaysia And Thailand In 2024 Export Growth - Nikkei Asia
Vietnam stood out among its Southeast Asian peers last year with robust export growth, outpacing peer manufacturing hubs Malaysia and Thailand as the country benefitted from supply chain shifts away from China.
Using official statistics, Nikkei Asia compared the trade trends of five major ASEAN countries – Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, and the Philippines being the others – for 2024. Another trade hub, Singapore, was excluded as its statistics are not comparable due to its large transit trade.
8. Lebanon Not Battleground For ‘Wars Of Others,’ President Aoun Tells Iran - AFP
Lebanon’s President Joseph Aoun told a visiting Iranian delegation that the war-scarred country was “tired” of external conflicts playing out on its territory. “Countries should not interfere in the internal affairs of other countries,” he added.
Aoun said Lebanon wanted “the best relations with Tehran, for the benefit of both countries and peoples.” Hezbollah’s weakening allowed Lebanon’s divided parliament to elect Aoun, seen as Washington’s preferred candidate, after more than two years of presidential vacuum, followed by the approval of a new prime minister and government.
9. Germany's Merz Eyes 'Independence' From U.S., Airs Worries About NATO's Future - RFE/RL
Friedrich Merz, the presumptive next German chancellor and a longtime supporter of transatlantic ties, said he now seeks security “independence” from the U.S. and expressed doubts about the future of NATO.
Merz, leader of the center-right CDU/CSU alliance, said he had "no illusions at all about what is coming out of America."
10. German Far-Right AfD Sees Historic Gains, Still Out Of Power - D.W.
The Alternative for Germany party (AfD), just 12 years after the far-right party was founded, has become the second largest political force in Germany. With around 20% of the vote, it almost doubled its result from the last German election in 2021.
Despite its success, as well as support from Elon Musk and JD Vance, it has no chance of participating in government. The AfD lead candidate Alice Weidel lashed out at the CDU's leader and likely next chancellor Friedrich Merz, saying, "They wanted to halve us, but the opposite has happened!"
11. North Korea Denounces New Sanctions Group; Says Sanctions Not ‘A Concern’ - RFA
North Korea criticized a new South Korea-led grouping set up to monitor the implementation of sanctions against it, saying it would thrive no matter what and it was not desperate to get sanctions lifted.
The Multilateral Sanctions Monitoring Team, or MSMT, established by South Korea and 10 other countries, including the U.S. and Japan, in October, began work last week, pledging to ensure the full implementation of U.N. sanctions against North Korea.
12. India Bans Two Opioids Behind Crisis In West Africa - BBC
BBC Eye found one pharmaceutical company, Aveo, had been illegally exporting a harmful mix of tapentadol and carisoprodol in countries like Ghana, Nigeria, and Cote D'Ivoire.
In a letter from India's Drugs Controller General, Dr Rajeev Singh Raghuvanshi said permission to manufacture and export the drugs had been withdrawn. India's Food and Drug Administration said the company's factory in Mumbai had since been raided and its entire stock seized.
13. Sakana AI To Revise Breakthrough Claims Amid Online Criticism Of Results - Nikkei Asia
Tokyo-based startup Sakana AI followed its original announcement with a statement on Friday saying it will revise its paper and update its results, without going into detail about what that update might look like.
The announcement comes after online engineers pointed out that its results were flawed. The Japanese company had said it had found a way to accelerate AI training and deployment by up to 100 times through auto-generating and optimizing code used to control Nvidia's graphic processing units.
14. Indonesia Launches New Multi-Billion-Dollar Sovereign Wealth Fund - AFP
The new sovereign wealth fund will manage state assets worth more than $900 billion, and President Prabowo Subianto wants to turbo-charge growth in Southeast Asia's biggest economy.
The recently inaugurated leader has pledged to take the archipelago's annual growth from five to eight percent, ordering billions of dollars worth of cuts across government that last week sparked the first protests of his rule. The new fund known as Daya Anagata Nusantara, or Danantara, is modeled on Singapore's investment arm Temasek.
15. Warren Buffett Just Issued His Most Daunting Warning to Wall Street Yet. It Couldn't Be Any Clearer - The Motley Fool
In Berkshire's latest 13F, Buffett made a tumultuous warning to Wall Street about the stock market. In 2024, Buffett and Berkshire hoarded cash and had over $320 billion of cash and short-term Treasury bills at the end of the third quarter.
Berkshire also sold more stocks than it bought in 2024, including big chunks of some of its largest positions like Apple and Bank of America. Berkshire exited two exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that track the broader market: the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) and the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO).
16. Bitcoin To Deliver ‘High Returns' For 30 Years, Predicts Top Mathematician - TheStreet
Bitcoin is still in its early days, and its price is poised for “massively high returns” over the next two to three decades, according to Wall Street veteran and mathematician Fred Krueger.
“We're at the beginning of probably a 20-year journey of massively high returns. It’s going to be… 20 or maybe even 30 years,” Krueger said in an interview on Jamie Tree podcast. Krueger dismissed the idea that Bitcoin has already peaked, emphasizing that despite its rapid growth, it remains in the “first inning” of its long-term trajectory. He compared it to major tech stocks like Apple and Amazon, where even after early surges, valuations continued to skyrocket.
17. Overdose Deaths Decline In U.S. Driven By Fewer Opioid Fatalities - HealthDay News
Drug overdose deaths decreased by 4% between 2022 and 2023, according to the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics. This reduction was driven by a decline in OD deaths related to opioids, the report says.
However, OD deaths increased among users of stimulant drugs like methamphetamine and cocaine, researchers noted. Across the country, drug OD deaths decreased in 20 states and did not change significantly in 25 states, researchers found.
