AI Is Pointless If It Doesn’t Boost Productivity

By Jim O'Neill, Project Syndicate | September 23, 2025

If all those pushing AI want it to serve society, they should develop a serious, clear, evidence-based plan to ensure that the technology contributes to productivity growth where it is needed most. Otherwise, we all must ask what the current massive sums of investment are for.

LONDON – It has become all but impossible to ignore the breathless media coverage of AI. The technology’s accelerating progress is treated as an inevitability, a prospect that induces both excitement and existential fears about the future. Judging by the lofty stock-market valuations of firms on the cutting edge of the industry, markets seem convinced that we have entered a technological revolution.

And yet I have reassessed my own outlook. As an economist, my view in recent years was that groundbreaking innovations in AI should be a net positive, because that has been the case with the arrival of new technologies throughout my career. Reality never vindicated arguments by techno-skeptics and pessimists that some new technology would create a crisis of mass unemployment, so my default view was that this time should be no different. Moreover, AI could be a godsend for Western societies confronting problems such as a rapidly aging workforce, political backlashes against immigration, and rising government debt burdens.

But the response I often hear from those most deeply immersed in the field is that I don’t “get” how frighteningly fast AI development is proceeding. I have failed to appreciate just how dangerous the technology could be, especially if it reaches the point where it can adapt its own thinking without any input from its controller. By the same token, if AI ends up in the wrong hands – be it criminal organizations or rogue states – it could cause political and social havoc.

And then there is the extraordinary cost of producing and operating this technology. We just watched US President Donald Trump visit the United Kingdom, and alongside all the pomp and ceremony was an intense focus on mobilizing even more investment in data centers and the energy infrastructure to power them.

Given the unprecedented market valuations and the sheer scale of the sums involved, I must ask: What, exactly, is the purpose? If AI, with all its obvious power, cannot be marshaled in ways that materially solve our biggest problems, what will all this have been for? I can see why the owners of the leading companies want all other businesses to adopt AI. But that does not mean the technology will help us address the biggest, most persistent challenges that our societies face.

For private-sector employers, AI does seem like an obvious way to keep labor costs in check. Most economists would welcome anything that can shock corporate executives out of focusing so much on the need for cheap, flexible labor. But this issue is not especially important in the big picture.

In the UK, for example, productivity growth has been weak ever since the 2008 financial crisis, and if you dig into the data, you find that key public-sector institutions are a major factor. Yet while everyone talks about boosting productivity at the National Health Service, no one has really made it a high priority.

When I served on the independent Times Health Commission in 2023, I often had to push back on the widely shared view that, regardless of what we might recommend, health spending as a share of GDP would inevitably continue to rise. But why should this be the case? In the late 1970s, health spending as a share of GDP was about the same as education – around 5%. But today it is closer to 12% of GDP, more than double that of education.

To my economist’s eye, these trend lines make no sense. If anything, education spending ought to be higher than health-care spending, because better educated young people can both boost the productivity of the future workforce and make better health choices. It may also be easier to achieve higher productivity in health care than in teaching. Making matters worse, the more that spending on health care rises, the more difficult it is to avoid spending cuts in other areas, barring more large tax hikes. The UK Office for Budget Responsibility continues to project horrendous levels of potential government debt by 2050 unless we do something about the NHS, welfare payments, public pensions, and other social services.

So, my recommendation to public policymakers, industry leaders, and others is to develop a serious, clear, evidence-based plan to ensure that AI contributes to productivity growth where it is needed most. It won’t necessarily be easy, but with all the brain power and talent being deployed to develop the technology, surely someone can figure out how to put it to good use.

Jim O’Neill is a former UK Treasury minister and a former chairman of Goldman Sachs Asset Management.

Copyright Project Syndicate

1. Trump Criticizes UN During Address, But Says The U.S. Behind It ‘100%’ – AP

President Donald Trump returned to the United Nations on Tuesday to boast of his second-term foreign policy achievements and lash out at the world body as a feckless institution, while warning Europe it would be ruined if it doesn’t turn away from a “double-tailed monster” of ill-conceived migration and green energy policies.

Later, in a bilateral meeting with UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres, Trump’s tone toward the United Nations shifted after his speech earlier in the day blasted the world body for issuing “empty words.”

“Our country is behind the United Nations 100 per cent,” Trump told Guterres. “I may disagree with it sometimes but I am so behind it because the potential for peace at this institution is great.”

2. Ukraine Faces A New Test As Russia Steps Up Its Drive To Seize Donetsk’s Fortress Belt - AP

Fall is expected to bring another grueling test for Ukraine’s armed forces as Russia intensifies its campaign to seize an eastern region, once Ukraine’s industrial heartland and a territory it has long sought to conquer.

Russia now controls about 70% of the Donetsk region. Ukraine's forces have been pushed back to a string of four cities that analysts have dubbed its “fortress belt,” where they've repelled Moscow's efforts to seize the region for years.

3. Trump Says Ukraine Can Win Back Territory From Russia, Shifting His Tone On The War - CNN

President Donald Trump said Tuesday that Ukraine could restore its borders from before Russia’s invasion and that he believes NATO member countries should shoot down Russian aircraft if they enter their airspace, escalating his rhetoric against the Kremlin as its war in Ukraine drags on.

Taken together, Trump’s remarks on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly about shooting down Russian aircraft and his later post on Truth Social about Ukraine’s borders seemed to reflect a significant shift in his attitude toward Moscow and what the end of the intractable conflict might look like.

4. Iran's Supreme Leader Rejects Direct Talks With U.S. Over His Country's Nuclear Program - AP

Iran's supreme leader on Tuesday rejected direct negotiations with the United States over his country's nuclear program, likely slamming the door shut on a last-ditch effort to halt the reimposition of United Nations sanctions on Tehran.

Ayatollah Ali Khamenei's remarks, aired on Iranian state television, likely constrain any possible outreach to the U.S. by Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian, who is in New York for the U.N. General Assembly. Separately, Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi held meetings with diplomats from France, Germany, and the United Kingdom regarding the reimposition of sanctions, set to take effect on Sunday.

5. Japan, U.S., South Korea Say North Korea Denuclearization Not Off The Table - Kyodo News

Japan, the United States, and South Korea reaffirmed their "resolute commitment" to the complete denuclearization of North Korea on Monday, according to the top diplomats of the three countries, as Pyongyang set conditions for resuming diplomacy with Washington.

During a meeting in New York, Japanese Foreign Minister Takeshi Iwaya, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and South Korean Foreign Minister Cho Hyun confirmed that they remain on the same page on North Korea and voiced concern over frequent destabilizing actions around Taiwan, without naming China, according to a joint statement.

6. Air India Crash: Court Criticizes 'Prejudicial' Actions Of Regulator - UPI

India's aviation authorities received a stern rebuke from the country's Supreme Court for suggesting that one of the pilots bore responsibility, through either blunder or intent, for the Air India disaster in June.

The court on Monday issued notices to the Air Accident Investigation Bureau and Civil Aviation Directorate General, saying it was "irresponsible" for them to leak the suggestion that pilot error caused the crash, which killed all but one of the 242 passengers and crew and 19 people on the ground.

7. Fed's Powell Sees 'No Risk-Free Path' For Interest Rates After Central Bank's Cut Last Week – Yahoo Finance

It's "a challenging situation," Powell said during a speech in Rhode Island on Tuesday, reiterating that the Fed must balance its dual goals of maximum employment and price stability.

Powell on Tuesday repeated many of the same points he made last Wednesday after the central bank voted to cut interest rates 25 basis points and officials penciled in a median estimate of two more 25 basis point cuts by year-end.

8. Key GOP Lawmakers Back Trump's Executive Order For Crypto, Other Alternative Assets In 401(K) Plans – Fox News

A group of key Republican lawmakers in the House of Representatives signaled support for the Trump administration's move to allow alternative assets, including cryptocurrencies, in 401(k) plans.

House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill, R-Ark., and Subcommittee on Capital Markets Chair Ann Wagner, R-Mo., were joined by seven other GOP lawmakers when they wrote to Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chairman Paul Atkins on Monday to express support for the move.

They said President Donald Trump's executive order on the subject has the potential to enhance Americans' retirement savings and encouraged the SEC to work with the Labor Department in revising relevant regulations to make the investments more accessible.

9. Michelob Ultra Tops U.S. Beer Sales, Surpassing Modelo - TIPP Insights

Michelob Ultra is now America’s top-selling beer, overtaking Modelo Especial in U.S. retail sales by volume as of September 14, according to Circana data cited by CNN.

Anheuser-Busch credited the rise to aggressive marketing, including star endorsements like Lionel Messi and the rollout of Michelob Ultra Zero, its new non-alcoholic option.

10. Opinion: We’re Going Bold To Tackle Autism - By Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, Dr. Marty Makary and Dr. Mehmet Oz, Politico

President Donald Trump and HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. challenged us to break down the walls between our agencies so we can rapidly address the health crises facing the American people. Today, we announce an approach to provide relief for children on the autism spectrum.

Related: Responsible Acetaminophen, Editorial Board, TIPP Insights

📊 Market Pulse — September 23, 2025

📈 S&P 500 — 6,656.92 ▼ –0.55%
Equities slipped after Monday’s record highs as traders turned cautious ahead of Micron earnings and Powell’s remarks.

📉 10Y Treasury — 4.12% ▼ –2.3 bp
Yields eased, reflecting renewed demand for bonds amid uncertainty over the Fed’s next moves.

🛢️ Crude Oil — $63.61 ▲ +2.14%
Oil rebounded strongly after recent weakness, supported by supply headlines and bargain buying.

💵 US Dollar — 97.23 ▼ –0.11
The dollar softened slightly as investors weighed U.S. growth signals and global policy divergence.

🪙 Bitcoin — $112,003 ▼ –0.6%
Bitcoin drifted lower, consolidating within its recent trading range.

💰 Gold — $3,764.63 ▲ +0.46%
Gold extended its rally to fresh highs as rate-cut expectations and safe-haven demand stayed firm.