AI Will Not Supercharge GDP Growth

By Adair Turner - Project Syndicate | Feb 27, 2025

For good or ill – or merely as an enabler of ever more intense zero-sum competition – artificial intelligence will have a pervasive and perhaps transformative impact on society. But the hope that it will unleash a sustained increase in measured productivity and GDP growth is probably a delusion.

LONDON – Everyone knows that artificial intelligence is a hugely powerful technology with immense economic implications. US equity prices reflect not only confidence in the prospects of technology companies but also a belief that AI will fuel a broader boom. The growth-obsessed UK government views AI development as a top priority, and everyone at the World Economic Forum in Davos this January wanted to hear from the world’s AI leaders.

We have been here before. In the 1960s, computers were too enormous and expensive to be used by anyone but the largest government agencies and businesses. Yet so great were concerns about “automation” that US President Lyndon Johnson launched an inquiry into the danger that computer-based technologies might “eliminate all but a few jobs.” It wasn’t to be. By the 1970s, there was no sign of a productivity surge, and fears of mass technological unemployment subsided.

Personal and business computer use then soared in the 1980s; but by 1990, as the economist Robert Solow famously observed, Information Technology (IT) was “everywhere but in the productivity statistics.” With mobile phones, the internet, ever-expanding hardware capacity, and growing software capabilities promising a new connectivity-based productivity revolution, everyone at the World Economic Forum in 2000 wanted to hear from the leaders of “Information and Communications Technology” (ICT). Cisco CEO John Chambers predicted that ICT would enable the US economy to grow by 5% per year for the foreseeable future, and that “The internet will form half of gross domestic product by 2010.”

Then there was “big data,” “the digital economy,” “machine learning,” and now artificial intelligence. None, so far, has had any measurable impact on medium-term growth rates. A case can be made that generative AI, owing to its self-learning capability, represents more than just another stage of technological development. But there are still two reasons why it, too, may not show up in growth data.

First, a large and probably growing share of economic activity involves a zero-sum struggle for competitive advantage with no positive impact on either measured growth or human welfare. Using basic internet search, and now sophisticated large language models, lawyers are increasingly able to analyze every possible precedent before presenting their arguments. But if the opposing law firm can do the same, the result is an arms race in which neither party has a durable advantage.

For at least two decades, experts have warned that after the steady decline of manufacturing jobs, professional services such as the law would be next in line for automation. But employment and pay in the field of commercial law continue to grow.

Similarly, marketing departments can use AI to produce ever more targeted and effective communications to influence consumer choice. If their competitors are doing the same, however, there is no benefit to end consumers, and no boost to GDP.

Conversely, AI will almost certainly deliver huge human-welfare benefits almost for free. The late Martin Feldstein, writing in 2017, correctly observed this phenomenon at work in the previous three decades of remarkable IT and ICT progress. By then, smartphones boasted many thousands of times more processing power and memory than the biggest computers of the 1960s, enabling vastly more communication, data storage, video and image sharing, and so forth. Yet the share of GDP accounted for by the telecoms sector had hardly changed, leading Feldstein to conclude that “low growth estimates fail to reflect the remarkable innovations in everything from health care to Internet services to video entertainment that have made life better during these years.”

Likewise, Google DeepMind’s AlphaFold Protein Structure Database (which predicts a protein structure from its amino acid sequence) is set to accelerate drug discovery while slashing the cost of research. But once drugs come off patent, their prices fall toward their marginal cost of production, and their contribution to measured GDP collapses.

If, by 2070, an AI-enabled acceleration of knowledge acquisition has furnished us with a wonder drug that gives everyone a 100-year life of perfect health, and which is produced in wholly automated factories powered by cheap nuclear fusion, it will count for almost nothing in global GDP. The more powerful a technology, the more rapidly it disappears from measured GDP.

At the same time, AI will have massive potential to exacerbate the harms to human welfare that previous generations of ICT have already produced. Deepfake capabilities are already driving an explosion of online scams, and AI-powered social-media algorithms are deepening political polarization and probably contributing to what social psychologist Jonathan Haidt sees as an epidemic of mental illness among young people. Yet none of these negatives show up in measured GDP, either.

For good or ill – or merely as an enabler of ever more intense zero-sum competition – AI will have a pervasive and perhaps transformative impact on society. But the hope that it will unleash a sustained increase in measured productivity and GDP growth is probably a delusion.

Adair Turner, Chair of the Energy Transitions Commission, was Chair of the UK Financial Services Authority from 2008 to 2012. He is the author of many books, including Between Debt and the Devil: Money, Credit, and Fixing Global Finance (Princeton University Press, 2016).

Copyright Project Syndicate

1. Trump’s New Tariffs Will Be Effective From March 4 - TIPP Insights

Since assuming office in January, U.S. President Trump has begun to impose tariffs against other countries as part of his “America First” trade agenda – some of which come into effect in early March.

2. UK: Starmer Announces 'Coalition Of The Willing' To Guarantee Ukraine Peace - BBC

UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer has announced a four-point plan to work with Ukraine to end the war and defend the country from Russia.

He said the UK, France, and other countries will step up their efforts in a "coalition of the willing" and seek to involve the U.S. in their support for Ukraine. This was after calling a summit of 18 leaders—mostly from Europe and including Volodymyr Zelensky—three days earlier.

"We are at a crossroads in history today," Starmer said after the summit, while Zelensky said Kyiv felt "strong support" and the gathering showed "European unity at an extremely high level not seen for a long time".

3. Kremlin-Favored Candidate Declared Winner In Georgia's Breakaway Abkhazia Region - RFE/RL

Kremlin-favored candidate Badra Gunba won the presidential runoff in Abkhazia, a Russian-backed breakaway region that legally is a part of Georgia, de facto election authorities said.

Gunba, 47, failed to secure an outright majority in the first round on February 15, forcing the runoff against Adgur Ardzinba, a challenger critical of some Russian-backed economic policies. Turnout was reported at 70 percent.

4. Russia Offers To Restore Direct Air Links With The US, During Istanbul Talks - A.P.

The Russian Foreign Ministry said that during the latest round of consultations with Washington, Russia offered the United States to restore direct air links between the two countries.

Russian and U.S. diplomats met in Istanbul on Thursday to discuss normalizing the operation of their respective embassies that has been crippled by multiple round of diplomats' expulsions during previous years.

5. Xi Prepares To Unveil China Stimulus Plan As Trade War Heats Up - Bloomberg

Thousands of delegates including ministry chiefs and provincial leaders will gather Wednesday in Beijing for the parliamentary conclave, where officials will set a bullish growth goal of around 5%, according to most analysts surveyed by Bloomberg.

To get there, policymakers are expected to push China’s official budget deficit target to the highest in over three decades, pumping trillions of yuan into a system battling deflation, a property crash and now a trade war with the U.S.

6. China Eyeing U.S. Farm Exports For Retaliation, Report Says, As Importers Rush To Beat Tariffs - A.P.

The Global Times, a newspaper of China's ruling Communist Party, said that Beijing was studying both tariffs and non-tariff moves to counter Trump's higher tariffs.

Asked about that report, Foreign Ministry spokesman Lin Jian said that “China will take all necessary measures to firmly safeguard own legitimate rights and interests.” “U.S. agricultural and food products will most likely be listed,” it said, citing an unnamed source.

7. Iran’s 2015 Nuclear Deal Negotiator, Mohammad Javad Zarif, Resigns From VP Post Again - AFP

Iran’s former foreign minister, Mohammad Javad Zarif, who negotiated the landmark 2015 nuclear deal with world powers, has resigned as vice president, state media said.

In a Monday post on X, Zarif said he had “faced the most horrible insults, slander and threats against myself and my family, and I have gone through the most bitter period of my 40 years of service. “To avoid further pressure on the government, the head of the judiciary recommended that I resign and... I accepted immediately,” he added.

8. Vietnam Courts American Businesses, Pledges To Cut Surplus With U.S. - RFA

Vietnam’s prime minister met with dozens of U.S. business leaders over the weekend, seeking to smooth any possible trade issues with President Donald Trump's new administration.

Pham Minh Chinh told about 40 representatives of U.S. companies that Vietnam was taking steps to cut its large trade surplus, considering imports of aircraft, arms, natural gas, pharmaceuticals and other goods, Vietnam’s state-run Tuoi Tre news site reported.

9. U.S. Carrier Docks In South Korea After North's Missile Tests - D.W.

The USS Carl Vinson has entered the port of Busan, South Korea, in a show of force expected to enrage Pyongyang. The move comes just days after North Korea tested strategic cruise missiles.

The nuclear-powered vessel last visited Busan in November 2023. Another U.S. aircraft carrier, USS Theodore Roosevelt, was deployed to the harbor in June 2024 for joint military exercises.

10. Pope Francis Makes Call For World Peace From Hospital Bed - D.W.

"I pray above all for peace. From here, war appears even more absurd," Pope Francis, who is battling severe double pneumonia, delivered the speech in writing in place of his customary Sunday prayer with pilgrims.

When asking for prayers for the conflicts around the world, the 88-year-old pontiff specifically mentioned "Ukraine, Palestine, Israel, Lebanon, Myanmar, Sudan, and Kivu," a region in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo.

11. 3 Undervalued Dividend Aristocrats With Explosive Upside Potential - Barchart

Dividend Aristocrats are an elite group of S&P 500-listed companies that have increased their dividends for at least 25 consecutive years.

Amcor Plc is a packaging solution company that primarily serves food and healthcare companies. Its forward annual dividend is $0.505 per share, which translates to a yield of 5% and represents 70.58% of the company’s earnings. 

Federal Realty Investment Trust: This REIT  with over 100 properties has a forward annual dividend of $4.40 that translates to a 4.23% yield. They’ve increased their quarterly dividend for 57 consecutive years.

Stanley Black & Decker manufactures products under several names, including Craftsman, Stanley, Black + Decker, Hustler, and more. The company pays a forward dividend of $3.28, translating to a 3.83% yield.

12. Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, Solana, And Cardano Prices Soar After Trump Confirms U.S. Crypto Reserve - CoinMarketCap

Trump said the U.S. crypto reserve was necessary to counter what he called "years of corrupt attacks by the Biden administration" on the crypto industry.

He pointed to an executive order on digital assets directing officials to move forward with a "crypto strategic reserve," saying, "A U.S. crypto reserve will elevate this critical industry." Market analysts see the creation of a crypto reserve as a major step in the U.S. government’s approach to digital assets. Federico Brokate of ETF issuer 21Shares called it "a pivotal moment" for the industry.

13. Antidepressants Might Hasten Decline From Dementia - HealthDay News

Antidepressants are frequently prescribed to people with dementia for symptoms like anxiety, depression, aggressiveness, and sleeplessness.

But a specific class of antidepressant medications – selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors – actually might speed up brain decline among some dementia patients, a new Swedish study suggests. The SSRI drug escitalopram was associated with the fastest cognitive decline, followed by citalopram and sertraline. Mirtazapine, which works in a different way, had less negative impact on brain function, researchers found.