By Gordon Brown - Project Syndicate | Feb 10, 2025
Despite beginning the process of withdrawing the United States from the World Health Organization, President Donald Trump has suggested that he could be convinced to reverse course. To that end, the WHO must demonstrate progress on ensuring fair burden-sharing, strengthening country offices, and avoiding mission creep.
EDINBURGH – After announcing his intention to withdraw the United States from the World Health Organization, President Donald Trump has indicated that he might be willing to reconsider. At issue is one of Trump’s favorite themes: reciprocity and fair burden-sharing. He believes that China contributes too little and exerts too much influence over the WHO.
Trump is right to point out the importance of equitable burden-sharing. In fact, the WHO has already adopted measures suggested by its member states to address this imbalance. At present, only 26% of the WHO’s approved budget comes from assessed contributions, a membership fee of sorts based largely on a country’s share of global GDP and population (United Nations Peacekeeping, the International Monetary Fund, and the World Bank also use this approach). But member states are now on a path to financing at least 50% of the WHO’s main budget in proportion to their economic and population size by 2031.
Under the current formula, America’s portion of the assessed contributions is capped at 22% even though it accounts for 26% of global GDP. China now pays 15% and that percentage will continue to rise as the country’s share of global GDP grows.
The more that the WHO is financed through assessed contributions, the more that China, India, the Gulf petrostates, and several Central European countries will be obliged to contribute, ensuring that all countries pay their fair share. Of course, owing to America’s generosity, the US government has made contributions that go beyond normal member-state dues – hence its position as the largest donor to the WHO. China, for its part, currently gives little beyond what is required, but this should also change over the coming years.
Trump is equally concerned about China’s influence on the WHO and the country’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic. WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus shares some of these concerns. He has repeatedly called on China to investigate and disclose what happened in Wuhan five years ago and has drawn China’s condemnation by rightly insisting that, until that occurs, all hypotheses about the virus’s origin remain on the table.
Ironically, given the torrent of falsehoods about it, the pandemic accord under negotiation at the WHO would improve international health coordination and prevent similar failures from happening again. If this proposed instrument, as well as the updated international health regulations, were to require earlier reporting, full information-sharing, and a more rapid response to health threats, we could avoid repeating past mistakes. But the US will lose all influence over these negotiations if it leaves the WHO, while the Trump administration could instead use its clout within the organization to reach an agreement that the US can accept.
Trump also wants evidence of reform at the WHO. That means decentralization, with country and regional offices gaining greater authority vis-à-vis what he sees as an overly bureaucratic Geneva headquarters. It also implies avoiding the mission creep that often arises from member-state requests and earmarked funding designed to give priority to their own projects. The WHO must demonstrate progress on both issues in a transparent manner.
In fact, all WHO member states have requested reforms – both these and others – to enhance the organization’s performance, accountability, and transparency, as a quid pro quo for agreeing to increase the percentage of assessed contributions. They want a guarantee that the money will be spent efficiently, with timely results and fully operational internal controls.
The WHO has already made important progress. Tedros has, in fact, launched an ambitious plan to transform the organization, including by bolstering and delegating more authority to country offices. Moreover, in response to the recommendations of the Agile Member States Task Group, and following the Secretariat’s complementary implementation plan on reform, the WHO has become more transparent and accountable. It has improved internal control systems and developed a process for designing and implementing program budgets that involves member states to a greater degree and improves resource allocation, monitoring, and reporting. Systems for preventing and responding to sexual abuse and misconduct have also been a priority under Tedros’s leadership.
Perhaps most critically, Tedros himself has taken the initiative to resist the natural tendency of the World Health Assembly (the WHO’s decision-making body) to vote in new priorities and work areas. This has limited countries’ practice of earmarking funding for special-interest projects that would dilute the WHO’s purpose and strength.
In this age of mass travel, increasing urbanization, industrial livestock farming, and human encroachment on wildlife habitats, the need for the WHO is stronger now than it was in the 1850s, when the first formal international health conference was held in response to a cholera outbreak. Even more vigilance – and greater cross-border cooperation – is required if we are to prevent the spread of infectious diseases.
The last half-century has shown what such collaboration can achieve: smallpox was eradicated, polio and many tropical diseases are close to being eradicated, and HIV-related deaths have fallen by nearly 70%. But progress will falter if countries decide to go it alone.
That is why, to reassure the Trump administration and other governments, like Argentina, that are threatening to leave, there is a case for bringing together a group of highly respected leaders, representing every continent, and a top-level American official. They could be asked to show how the reformed WHO would best serve the global community – both the US and the rest of the world – now and in the future. We owe it to ourselves and future generations to do everything in our power to make global health cooperation the best it can be. We must never forget the medical lessons we have learned, from cholera to COVID: no one is safe until everyone is safe.
Gordon Brown, a former prime minister of the United Kingdom, is UN Special Envoy for Global Education and Chair of Education Cannot Wait.
Copyright Project Syndicate
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. American Marc Fogel Released From Russian Custody - Fox News
An American teacher who Russia detained is heading back to American soil, the Trump administration announced Tuesday.
"Today, President Donald J. Trump and his Special Envoy Steve Witkoff are able to announce that Mr. Witkoff is leaving Russian airspace with Marc Fogel, an American who was detained by Russia," National Security Adviser Mike Waltz said in a statement.
2. Hamas Says It Will Postpone Hostage Release, Blaming Israel - BBC
A spokesman for the armed wing of Hamas says the group is postponing the next scheduled release of Israeli hostages, blaming what he says are Israeli violations of the ceasefire deal.
Hamas spokesman Abu Obeida accused Israel of delaying the return of displaced Palestinians to the north of Gaza, firing on people and failing to allow in agreed humanitarian aid. Three hostages held in Gaza are due to be freed on Saturday in exchange for more Palestinian prisoners held in Israel.
3. Trump Doubles Down On Plan For US Control Of Gaza In Meeting With Jordan's King Abdullah II - Scripps News Group
President Trump reiterated his plan for the U.S. to take control of Gaza and have neighboring countries like Jordan and Egypt accept Palestinian refugees.
President Trump has also indicated that he hopes neighboring countries like Egypt and Jordan will be willing to accept Palestinian refugee settlements, something Jordan's King Abdullah said Tuesday will require further discussions with Egypt.
4. EU Chief Says U.S. Tariffs ‘Will Not Go Unanswered’ - PBS
U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminum “will not go unanswered,” European Union chief Ursula von der Leyen vowed on Tuesday, adding that they will trigger tough countermeasures from the 27-nation bloc. It means iconic U.S. industries like bourbon, jeans and motorcycles should beware.
“The EU will act to safeguard its economic interests,” von der Leyen said in a statement in reaction to U.S. President Donald Trump’s imposition of tariffs on steel and aluminum on Monday.
5. Envoy Will Visit Ukraine Soon, Trump Confirms As Munich Conference Meetings Are Set - RFE/RL
President Donald Trump said that he will speak with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy this week and his special envoy for Ukraine and Russia will go to Ukraine soon as a week of high-level diplomacy related to the Russia-Ukraine war got under way.
CNN reported the trip would take place next week, while AFP quoted a source in the Ukrainian presidency as saying the visit would take place on February 20. Kellogg is already expected to meet with Zelenskyy at the Munich Security Conference, which opens on February 14.
6. North Korea’s Increasingly Accurate Missiles Raise Concerns - RFA
North Korean ballistic missiles used by Russia in the Ukraine war are now capable of landing within 328 feet of their targets, causing serious concern to defenders and highlighting the benefits to North Korea of its weapons being tested on the battlefield.
Reuters quoted two senior Ukrainian sources as saying that all of the more than 20 North Korean missiles that hit Ukraine over the past several weeks showed “a marked improvement in the precision” compared with earlier in the war when the missiles had an accuracy of 3000 feet to 9000 feet.
7. China Hits Back At Washington Over Call For Jimmy Lai Release - RFA
The State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor said in a Feb. 7 post to its X account that Lai, 77, “has spent more than 1,500 days imprisoned while standing up bravely for democracy and free speech in Hong Kong.”
“We urge the HK government to immediately and unconditionally release Jimmy Lai,” the tweet said.
A spokesperson for the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Hong Kong said the remarks were “erroneous,” and accused Washington of “openly supporting anti-China and Hong Kong-disrupting element Jimmy Lai.”
8. Concerns Raised Over Potential Data Leak To China Via BYD Cars In S. Korea - Yonhap
With the recent entry by China's BYD Co. into South Korea's passenger electric vehicle (EV) market, concerns have been raised over potential personal data leaks to China through the vehicles manufactured by the company, industry observers said.
BYD's first model launched here, the Atto 3, is equipped with connected car features, such as over-the-air (OTA) software update capability and navigation features, through which sensitive driver data could be transferred to China, according to the market watchers.
9. New Zealand And Cook Islands Fall Out Over China Deal - BBC
New Zealand has accused the Cook Islands government of a lack of transparency over its plans to strike a partnership deal with China.
The tiny Pacific Island nation's leader, Mark Brown, is this week making his country's first-ever state visit to Beijing to sign the agreement. New Zealand says it was not properly consulted over the plans. The Cook Islands is hugely reliant on New Zealand under a longstanding "free association" agreement that provides it with defence and financial support.
10. China Tops Hedge Funds' Shopping Lists So Far This Year, Goldman Says - Reuters
Global hedge funds have been snapping up Chinese stocks for much of this year, with their buying accelerating in the past week as the emergence of homegrown artificial intelligence startup DeepSeek fueled investor enthusiasm, Goldman Sachs (GS) said in a note.
DeepSeek's breakthrough low-cost AI model has become a catalyst for the revaluation of Chinese assets among global investors that are already worried about the peaking valuation of U.S. stocks.
11. Marriages In China Plunged A Record 20% Last Year - TIPP Insights
The number of marriages in China dropped to 6.1 million in 2024, a record-breaking fall of 20.5% from the previous year – compounding the country’s plight with a declining population.
12. Iran Had Operatives In The U.S. To Shoot Down ‘Trump Force One’: Book - Al Arabiya
President Donald Trump had to fly on a decoy plane at least once while on the campaign trail last year after law enforcement officials suggested that Iran had placed operatives with access to surface-to-air missiles inside of the United States, according to a new book.
Last November, the U.S. Justice Department charged an Iranian man in connection with an alleged murder-for-hire plot to kill Trump while he was a presidential candidate.
13. Trump 'Considering' Australia Carve-Out On Steel And Aluminum Tariffs - Nikkei Asia
The U.S. will consider an exemption for Australia from the 25% tariff it imposed on steel and aluminum imports this week, leaders from both countries said after a phone call.
President Trump signed executive orders levying the tariffs on the materials at the White House. He told gathered journalists that there would be no "exceptions or exemptions" to the measures, which he claimed would boost American industry by bringing jobs and investment to the U.S.
14. India In Talks With U.S. To Buy Combat Vehicles, Seal Fighter Jet Engine Deal As Modi Visits, Sources Say - Reuters
The world's biggest arms importer, India traditionally relies mainly on Russia. Last month, Trump asked Modi, who heads to Washington for a two-day visit, to buy more U.S.-made security equipment and move "toward a fair trading relationship".
Modi is preparing additional tariff cuts ahead of his meeting with Trump that could boost American exports to India and avoid a potential trade war, government officials said.
15. U.S. Expects Israel To Fully Withdraw From Lebanon By Feb. 18: White House Source - Al Arabiya
The original agreement, mediated by the Biden administration, required Israel to withdraw its forces from Lebanon within 60 days of the Nov. 26 agreement. The Israeli forces were to be replaced by the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF).
With the deal expiring on Jan. 26, the U.S. announced that a “short, temporary ceasefire extension” was necessary to ensure Hezbollah could not threaten the Lebanese people or its neighbors. The new deadline was set for Feb. 18.
16. Vance Rails Against ‘Excessive’ Regulation At Paris AI Summit - AP
U.S. Vice President JD Vance on Tuesday warned global leaders and tech industry executives that “excessive regulation” could cripple the rapidly growing artificial intelligence industry in a rebuke to European efforts to curb AI’s risks.
At the summit, Vance made his first major policy speech since becoming vice president last month, framing AI as an economic turning point but cautioning that “at this moment, we face the extraordinary prospect of a new industrial revolution, one on par with the invention of the steam engine.”
“But it will never come to pass if overregulation deters innovators from taking the risks necessary to advance the ball,” Vance added.
17. Macron Says France Will Apply 'Notre Dame Strategy' On AI - D.W.
On the opening day of an AI summit in Paris co-hosted by India, French President Emmanuel Macron said a European AI strategy would be unveiled the following day at the event.
He declared that France was in the race for artificial intelligence development and called on attendees to choose Europe — broadly seen as lagging far behind the U.S. and China in the sector — for their business needs. He said "we will adopt the Notre Dame de Paris strategy" on AI projects that saw France rebuild the renowned cathedral in just five years after a devastating 2019 fire.
18. NEOM, Datavolt Sign Agreement To Launch $5 Bln AI Project - Reuters
Saudi Arabia’s NEOM, a Red Sea urban and industrial development, signed an agreement with DataVolt to develop a 1.5 GW net zero artificial intelligence project in the Saudi development’s Oxagon industrial zone, the Saudi state news agency reported.
19. Earth's Inner Core May Have Changed Shape, Say Scientists - BBC
The inner core - usually thought to be shaped like a ball - may have changed shape in the past 20 years, according to a group of scientists.
Its edges may actually have deformed by 100m or more in height in places, according to Prof. John Vidale who led the research. The inner core spins independently from the liquid outer core and from the rest of the planet. Without this motion, Earth would die and become more like barren Mars which lost its magnetic field billions of years ago.
20. Institutional Investors Buy The Crypto Dip For Fifth Straight Week - TheStreet
Inflows into crypto investment products, like Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs, notched total inflows for the fifth straight week as CoinShares counted $1.3 billion in total inflows in their latest report.
In fact, nearly $800 billion poured into Ethereum investment products last week after the crypto's recent 20% selloff. That was enough to pass Bitcoin inflows on a weekly clip for the first time this year.
21. People Most Happy In Morning, Study Finds - HealthDay News
People generally wake in their best frame of mind, enjoying peak mental health and wellbeing in the morning, researchers reported in a new study published in BMJ Mental Health.
They also tend to feel worst around midnight, with the day of the week and season of the year also playing a role, researchers found. Analysis revealed that people generally wake up in the morning feeling their best. They have their lowest levels of depression, anxiety and depression, and highest happiness and life satisfaction scores.
