By Radosław Sikorski, Project Syndicate | May 19, 2025
Given the Trump administration's attitude toward the transatlantic relationship, Europe faces an existential choice: enter the global game united, as a heavyweight competitor, or condemn itself to marginalization. Fortunately, the first option is already well within the European Union's means.
POZNAŃ – For years, I have taken every opportunity to urge the European Union and its member states to invest more in defense. When Russian President Vladimir Putin launched his full-scale invasion of Ukraine, I repeatedly asked (as a member of the European Parliament) what further proof we would need to recognize the threats facing all of Europe. What would we – as Europeans – do if our security was threatened while our closest ally, the United States, was otherwise engaged?
Today, we confront that very situation. US officials are openly stating that they do not intend to devote most of their time or resources to dealing with what they deem European issues. According to Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the US has “other priorities to focus on.”
I agree. The global superpower has global responsibilities, and the number of flash points that might demand the US government’s attention seems only to be growing. In addition to challenges in the Western hemisphere, instability in the Middle East, and severe tensions between two nuclear powers – India and Pakistan – there is also the paramount goal of redefining relations with China. Moreover, according to the official US Defense Department planning doctrine, the US can no longer fight more than one major war at a time.
The new US administration has been communicating its position plainly. “We’re here today to directly and unambiguously express that stark strategic realities prevent the United States of America from being primarily focused on the security of Europe,” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced in Brussels this February. And US Vice President J.D. Vance was even more direct, stating that “Europe’s entire security infrastructure … has been subsidized by the United States of America,” even though it is neither in Europe’s nor America’s interest “for Europe to be a permanent security vassal of the United States.” President Donald Trump himself has repeatedly accused Europe of “freeloading” and “taking advantage” of the US.
Europeans may not like what we hear, but we cannot pretend not to hear it. We must be prepared for the US to wash its hands not only of Ukraine, but even of Europe. Le Monde’s Sylvie Kauffmann recently argued, “Preparing for the worst is a safer bet than hoping for the best.” We can and should do both – hope and prepare. Trust but verify.
Ever since Trump announced his presidential candidacy back in 2015, there have been two schools of thought on interpreting his words. Some argue that we should take him seriously but not literally, whereas others urge us to do the opposite: treat him literally but not always seriously. I believe that the most reasonable and respectable approach is to treat whatever the US president says both literally and seriously.
Given the current state of the world, this implies that Europe faces an existential choice. We can enter the global game united, as a heavyweight competitor, or we can condemn ourselves to marginalization.
Much has been done already to become a heavyweight contender. Since 2016 – just before Trump’s first term – NATO members, excluding the US, have increased their annual defense spending by 98%, from $255 billion to $506 billion. Moreover, after three years of Putin waging war on Ukraine, the EU and its member states have proven willing to spend even more and to embrace a more cooperative, rational, and effective approach to defense planning and procurement. The new joint defense agreement between the EU and the United Kingdom is another step demonstrating this new strategic solidarity.
Deterring Russia is not beyond our means. We don’t need to match US military capabilities; rather, we just need enough to force Putin to reconsider his chances of winning in a confrontation with a united European community of democratic nation-states.
The people of Europe are clearly demanding that we develop a revitalized European defense posture. According to the European Commission, 71% of EU citizens believe that the bloc must strengthen its ability to produce military equipment, while 77% support a common defense and security policy. This gives European leaders a mandate to think and act boldly.
But how long will it take to restore peace to Ukraine and stability to Europe? I believe we must act on the basis of three assumptions. First, we should view this as a war of a former imperial metropole against what it regards as a mutinous colony. History suggests that colonial wars usually take about a decade to end. Anything less than that should be considered a bonus.
Second, we should accept that for the invading country to start negotiating in good faith, it must conclude that the invasion was a mistake. It must acknowledge that the costs of war, and of keeping the former colony subjugated, are greater than whatever benefits the colony can possibly yield. Third, given the above, we should remember that colonial wars are usually finished by a different group of leaders than those who started the fighting.
Yes, boosting European defense capabilities while supporting Ukraine will cost money. Since the start of Russia’s war of aggression, the EU and its member states have provided more than $165 billion in support for Ukraine and its people. That is a significant amount, but it is still less than 1% of the combined GDP of the EU’s member countries (some $19 trillion). We can certainly do more.
And as we reinvigorate Europe’s defenses, we must not lose sight of why we are doing it: we are acting for our own safety, not to undermine transatlantic relations but to improve them. To avoid a strategic dilemma, we Europeans must be able to help the US defend its allies by taking on our fair share of the security burden.
This commentary is published in partnership with ImpactCEE.
Radosław Sikorski is Foreign Minister of Poland.
Copyright Project Syndicate
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. Putin Makes Surprise Visit To Russia's Kursk Region Amid Accusations of Stalling Peace Talks - RFE/RL
President Vladimir Putin made a surprise visit to Russia's Kursk region, his first since Russian troops pushed out Ukrainian troops who had been occupying parts of the region since launching an incursion last year.
Putin's visit comes amid accusations that he is stalling peace talks to end Europe's largest and deadliest conflict since World War II in an attempt to gain as much territory as possible to strengthen his hand at the negotiating table.
2. New EU-UK Agreements Have Common Thread: Russia - RFE/RL
While most attention in the run-up to the EU-UK meeting was thorny issues such as access to British fishing waters for EU vessels and agri products from the UK entering the bloc’s internal market, the common threat, Russia, is clearly underlined in the agreed documents.
The Security and Defense Partnership states that “the European Union (EU) and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (UK) face a volatile and increasingly challenging security environment in Europe and in its broader neighborhood, as demonstrated by Russia’s unprovoked and unjustified war of aggression against Ukraine.
3. Surging China Game Console Exports To Russia Spark Dual-Use Fears - Kyodo News
Chinese exports of video game consoles to Russia have jumped nearly sevenfold since 2022, after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, raising concerns that such devices could be diverted for military use.
In 2024, China shipped $95.38 million worth of gaming devices, including controllers, to Russia, according to customs data released. Earlier this year, Japan, Britain and the European Union banned the export of game controllers to Russia, citing concerns that such devices could be repurposed to operate drones on the battlefield in Ukraine.
4. U.S. Export Curbs On AI Chips To China 'A Failure' — Nvidia - D.W.
"I think, all in all, the export control was a failure," Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang said, underpinning that companies would use the "second best" option if they couldn't get chips from the American AI leader.
"The local companies are very, very talented and very determined, and the export control gave them the spirit, the energy and the government support to accelerate their development," Huang said addressing the media at a tech show in Taiwan.
5. Israel 'Completely Rejects' EU Decision To Review Trade And Cooperation Deal - Euronews
Israel has said it rejects a decision by the European Union to review the bloc's wide-ranging trade and cooperation pact with the country over its intensified offensive in Gaza.
The EU's foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas had stated that the bloc would examine if Israel has violated its human rights obligations under Article 2 of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, which defines the trading and diplomatic relations between both sides.
6. South Africa Downgrades Taiwan Status, Signaling More China Influence, Say Experts - RFA
South Africa’s Department of International Relations and Cooperation now categorizes the Taiwan Liaison Office – which functions as a de facto embassy but without official diplomatic status – as a “Taipei Commercial Office” on its official website, and has removed the name of the Taiwanese Representative Oliver Liao under the listing.
Analysts say that the changes highlight China’s continued efforts to use its influence in Africa and the Global South. South Africa severed formal diplomatic ties with Taiwan in 1997 and recognized Beijing as the government of China. But in the nearly three decades since, it has retained unofficial ties with Taipei and a trading relationship.
7. Canada In Talks With US To Join Trump's Golden Dome Defence System - BBC
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney's office said there are "active discussions" between Canada and the U.S. on security, including on existing and new programmes like the Golden Dome.
President Donald Trump unveiled the plan for the new missile defence system on Tuesday, announcing an initial price tag of $25bn. Canada's openness to joining the proposed Golden Dome system comes amid ongoing trade and security negotiations between the two countries.
8. Biden Aides Secretly Ran The Presidency: Trump - TIPP Insights
President Donald Trump accused former President Joe Biden’s White House team of treason, claiming they exploited Biden’s cognitive decline to enact policies he never supported, including opening the southern border.
In a Truth Social post, Trump alleged Biden’s aides hijacked the presidency using an autopen to approve border policies that have allowed criminals to enter the U.S. “They stole the presidency and put us in great danger,” Trump wrote, calling them “treasonous thugs.”
Related Editorial: All The President’s Hidden Men
9. Trump Shows Ramaphosa Videos Of Persecution Of White Farmers - TIPP Insights
President Donald Trump hosted South African President Cyril Ramaphosa in the Oval Office on Wednesday, where tensions emerged over the attack on White farmers in South Africa.
After dimming the lights, Trump played video clips of what's happening in South Africa. Ramaphosa watched silently before responding, “I’d like to know where that is, because this I’ve never seen.” Trump insisted it was from South Africa.
10. Ramaphosa To Trump: G-20 Needs U.S. At The Table - TIPP Insights
South African President Cyril Ramaphosa said that he hopes President Donald Trump will attend the G-20 summit later this year, as South Africa prepares to hand over the presidency of the forum to the United States.
“We are privileged and honored to be the president of G-20, but we are overjoyed to hand it over to the U.S., where it originated,” Ramaphosa said alongside Trump in the Oval Office. “For that reason, I expect the U.S. to continue playing the leadership role along with other countries.”
11. EU Releases Funding To Keep Radio Free Europe Afloat - D.W.
The European Union is providing €5.5 million ($6.2 million) to support Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL) after the broadcaster lost U.S. public funding.
The EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said the bloc is releasing the emergency funding as a "safety net for independent journalism." President Donald Trump's administration suspended funding to the 75-year-old broadcaster in March, accusing it of promoting a news agenda with liberal bias. Founded during the Cold War, the broadcaster's aim was to deliver news to people under communist rule.
12. Poll Shows Extent Of Anti-U.S. Feelings By European Consumers - TIPP Insights
A new survey finds that the majority of consumers in Germany, France, Italy, Switzerland, and Austria are likely to boycott American products such as iPhones in response to President Trump’s tariffs.
13. Japanese Farm Minister Resigns After Saying He Never Had To Buy Rice - UPI
Japanese Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, or Farms Taki Eto resigned after his comments over the price of rice led to a national backlash.
"My remarks were extremely inappropriate at a time when the public is suffering greatly from the rising prices of rice, and for that I offer my sincere apologies," Eto. Eto made the comments at a weekend fundraising event, where during a speech he said he had never bought rice, as he receives so much from his supporters.
14. Oil Climbs On Report That Israel Is Preparing To Strike Iran - Bloomberg
Oil has been volatile since last week on mixed headlines about the fate of Iran-U.S. nuclear talks, which could pave the way for more barrels to return to a market that’s expected to be oversupplied later in the year.
An attack by Israel would hinder any progress in those negotiations and add to unrest in the Middle East, which supplies about a third of the world’s crude. It wasn’t clear whether a final decision on any attack had been made, CNN said, citing U.S. intelligence and unidentified American officials.
15. Bitcoin Breaks $109K To Hit All-Time High - TIPP Insights
Bitcoin hit a new all-time high Wednesday, reaching $109,500 before settling around $108,955, a 2% gain on the day.
This surpasses the previous record set in January 2025. It marks a strong rebound from April’s low of $74,000.
16. Recovering From Heart Attack? Here's What You Shouldn't Do - HealthDay News
Within a year of being treated for heart attack symptoms, people who sat around afterwards for more than 14 hours a day on average were at greater risk for another heart-related health emergency, researchers reported.
Those with the lowest activity levels had 2.5 times the risk of another heart problem or death within the following year, results show. Results showed that replacing a half-hour of sedentary time with a half-hour of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity every day reduced the risk of heart attack, stroke or death by 61%.
