By Yi Fuxian, Project Syndicate
When Donald Trump complains that Chinese exports have contributed to the decline of US manufacturing, he has a point. But no one has paid a higher price for Chinese overcapacity than China, which is now staring down the barrel of demographic collapse.
MADISON, WISCONSIN – US President Donald Trump’s embrace of tariffs has been met with considerable criticism, and for sound reasons. But Trump’s diagnosis of the global trading system – and, specifically, its impact on US manufacturing – may not be entirely wrong. The problem, instead, is the treatment: rather than using a chainsaw, which would probably kill the patient, he should reach for a scalpel.
The existing international order, including the global trading system and the dollar-based monetary system, were established in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, near the end of World War II. With Europe in ruins, the United States enjoyed undisputed economic dominance, including in manufacturing: in 1948, four years after the Bretton Woods conference, the US accounted for more than half of all goods produced worldwide.
But one product of that conference – fixed exchange rates – turned out not to be all that good for the US, as it contributed to the precipitous decline of America’s share of global manufacturing value-added, from 55% in 1953 to 24% in 1970. US President Richard Nixon’s 1971 decision to delink the US dollar from gold mostly stabilized this share, which then remained roughly consistent for three decades. But it also turned the US from a surplus country into the world’s largest deficit country, as it fueled the rise of Japanese manufacturing.
The 1985 Plaza Accord – whereby the US convinced the rest of the G5 (Japan, West Germany, France, and the United Kingdom) to help weaken the dollar – succeeded in shrinking America’s external trade deficit. But these gains were eroded in 1994, when the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) went into effect, and obliterated after 2001, when China’s accession to the World Trade Organization opened the floodgates for Chinese goods to pour into the US market. In 2001-21, the ratio of US manufacturing exports to imports plummeted from 65% to 45%, and America’s share of global manufacturing value-added declined from 25% to 16%.
So, when Trump complains that Chinese exports have contributed to the decline of US manufacturing, he has a point (the extent to which reducing Chinese imports today would revitalize US manufacturing is another matter altogether). But no one has paid a higher price for Chinese overcapacity than China.
Children are “super consumers”: the more children a household contains, the more it spends. But decades of fertility-control policies have left China with relatively few children. In 1982, three years after the one-child policy was introduced, the country’s total population-to-worker ratio stood at 2.2, reflecting a relatively large number of dependents for each worker (aged 20-59). By 2010, the ratio had plummeted to 1.6, well below the international average of 1.8-2.2. (While this ratio is now rising again in China, it is being driven primarily by an increase in the number of elderly, not children.)
As households shrank, so did their incomes – from 62% of GDP in 1983 to 44% of GDP today. The result has been low and falling consumer demand: since 1983, household consumption has fallen from 53% of GDP to just 39% of GDP, compared to nearly 70% in the US.
Weak domestic consumption left China dependent on a manufacturing surplus – which reached $1.86 trillion, or 10.5% of GDP, in 2023 – to provide jobs. Because the US not only has a huge and voracious consumer market, but also issues the world’s primary reserve currency – and thus provides the world with trade surpluses and liquidity – American overconsumption became the natural counterweight to Chinese overcapacity.
This relationship, which historian Niall Ferguson and economist Moritz Schularick dubbed “Chimerica,” initially seemed symbiotic. But it quickly morphed into something monstrous, as it simultaneously destroyed US manufacturing – I was warning of a US-China trade war as far back as 2009 – and perpetuated the imbalance between production and consumption within China. In other words, China’s demographic collapse led to overcapacity.
China’s government has few options for addressing its demographic crisis. Its attempts to loosen fertility rules – replacing the one-child policy with a two-child and then a three-child limit – failed miserably, because low household incomes meant that families could not afford to have more children.
The government seems to be pinning its hopes on an “engineer dividend,” as China boasts more engineering graduates than the rest of the world combined. But college graduates typically find jobs in the services sector, which accounts for only 46% of Chinese employment. When other countries reached China’s current tertiary enrollment rate, their service sectors provided 70-80% of jobs. Little wonder that youth unemployment is skyrocketing in China, and the number of new marriages – the backbone of fertility – are plummeting.
By imposing sweeping tariffs on America’s trading partners, Trump risks severely weakening – or even destroying – the global trading system. Since it is China’s trade surplus that perfectly mirrors America’s trade deficit, any effort to revive US manufacturing should start there. Unfortunately for Trump, the only real solution is to boost China’s fertility rate, and that demands rapid progress in raising Chinese household incomes – something no tariff can achieve.
Yi Fuxian, a senior scientist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, spear-headed the movement against China’s one-child policy and is the author of Big Country with an Empty Nest (China Development Press, 2013), which went from being banned in China to ranking first in China Publishing Today’s 100 Best Books of 2013 in China.
Copyright Project Syndicate
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. Iran Open To Nuclear Deal But Won’t Halt Uranium Enrichment - TIPP Insights
Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmail Baghaei told CNN on Monday that Iran signaled readiness to compromise in nuclear talks with the United States but declared uranium enrichment non-negotiable.
While emphasizing Iran’s right to peaceful nuclear energy, Baghaei said there are “many ways” to reach a deal, if the U.S. isn’t trying to strip Iran of that right.
2. Everyone Is Emotional, Says Kremlin, After Trump Calls Putin 'Absolutely Crazy' - BBC
The Russian government replies by thanking Trump for his work on fostering negotiations with Ukraine, and says: "This is a very important moment which is connected to an emotional overload of everyone involved."
The Kremlin’s response to Donald Trump calling Vladimir Putin “absolutely CRAZY” is pointedly polite, especially by Russia’s standards, said Vitaliy Shevchenko, Russia editor, BBC Monitoring.
3. Ukraine Now Free To Strike Military Targets In Russia With Western Arms, Germany Says - Al Arabiya
Chancellor Friedrich Merz said that Germany along with Ukraine’s other key Western backers had lifted range restrictions on weapons they send to Kyiv to fight against Russia.
“There are no longer any range restrictions on weapons delivered to Ukraine – neither by the British nor by the French nor by us nor by the Americans,” Merz said. “This means that Ukraine can now defend itself, for example, by attacking military positions in Russia... With very few exceptions, it didn’t do that until recently. It can now do that.”
4. Amid Trump’s War On Harvard, Academia, China Steps In To Attract Global Talent: Report - News18.com
An example of this shift is former Harvard chemist Charles Lieber, who recently took up a post at Tsinghua University’s Shenzhen campus. Lieber had been convicted in 2021 in the U.S. for concealing ties to Chinese research funding.
He is among a small but growing group of senior Western scholars now relocating to China, while others, like Nobel-winning physicist Gérard Mourou and celebrated mathematician Kenji Fukaya, have joined Chinese institutions by choice, according to a report by the Economist.
Beijing, under Xi Jinping, has made attracting global talent a national priority. A plan rolled out in 2021 set goals to make China a top global destination for talent by 2030 and the leading one by 2035.
5. Racing Ahead Of U.S.: China Claims 600-Second RDE Test In Hypersonic Push, Raising Global Military Stakes - Business Today
In a move that could reshape the future of high-speed aviation and global defense strategy, China claims it has achieved a major breakthrough in hypersonic engine technology.
A team of scientists has reportedly run a “Rotating Detonation Engine” (RDE) for a record 600 seconds — an advance that, if verified, could tilt the balance in the ongoing race for hypersonic supremacy between China, the U.S., and Russia. Unlike traditional engines, which rely on combustion, the RDE uses controlled detonations to deliver higher thrust while consuming less fuel.
6. China Auto Shares Sink After BYD Offers Trade-In Incentives - Reuters
Shares in Chinese automakers such as BYD, Nio and Geely tumbled on Monday after industry leader BYD offered fresh incentives on over 20 models and the CEO of Great Wall Motors warned that the world's largest auto industry was in an unhealthy state.
Chinese electric vehicle giant BYD over the weekend announced a fresh round of subsidies and incentives for more than 20 models, which reduced the starting price of its cheapest model, the pure battery-powered Seagull hatchback, to 55,800 yuan ($7,765).
7. U.S. Steel To Remain In The U.S., Trump Announces Partnership With Nippon - TIPP Insights
President Donald Trump announced a major partnership between U.S. Steel and Japan’s Nippon Steel that will keep the American steel giant headquartered in Pittsburgh.
“This will be a planned partnership… which will create at least 70,000 jobs and add $14 billion to the U.S. economy,” Trump wrote on Truth Social. He said most of the investment would be made over the next 14 months, calling it the largest in Pennsylvania’s history.
8. Trump Delays EU Tariffs Until July 9 - TIPP Insights
President Donald Trump has delayed his proposed 50% tariffs on European Union imports until July 9, following a weekend call with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. He said she requested more time for “serious negotiation.”
French President Emmanuel Macron welcomed the move, calling the Trump–von der Leyen exchange a “good” one and reiterating his belief that tariffs are “not the right way” to resolve trade imbalances. Speaking in Vietnam, Macron said he hoped the U.S. and EU could “return to the lowest possible tariffs.”
9. Hamas Agrees To U.S. Proposal On Gaza Ceasefire, Palestinian Official Says - Reuters
Hamas has agreed to a proposal by U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff for a Gaza ceasefire, a Palestinian official close to the group told Reuters on Monday, paving the way for a possible end to the war with Israel.
“The proposal includes the release of ten living Israeli hostages held by Hamas in two groups in return for a 70-day ceasefire and a partial withdrawal from the Gaza Strip,” the source said. The proposal also sees the release of a number of Palestinian prisoners by Israel, including hundreds serving lengthy prison terms.
10. U.S. Homeland Security Chief Says Had ‘Candid’ Conversation With Netanyahu About Iran Talks - Reuters
“President Trump specifically sent me here to have a conversation with the prime minister about how those negotiations are going and how important it is that we stay united and let this process play out,” Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said during an interview with Fox News.
Iranian and U.S. delegations wrapped up a fifth round of talks in Rome last week and signs of some limited progress emerged.
11. Macron Calls Viral Slap A Joke. No One’s Laughing - TIPP Insights
French President Emmanuel Macron is pushing back against speculation over a viral video showing his wife, Brigitte, appearing to shove his face aside as they exited a plane in Vietnam.
“There’s a video showing me joking and teasing my wife and somehow that becomes a sort of geo-planetary catastrophe,” Macron told reporters in Hanoi, brushing off the clip as harmless.
12. The U.S. Military Spent $6 Billion In The Past 3 Years To Recruit And Retain Troops - NBC News
According to funding totals provided by the services, the financial incentives to reenlist in the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines increased dramatically from 2022 through last year, with the Navy vastly outspending the others.
The overall amount of recruiting bonuses also rose steadily, fueled by significant jumps in spending by the Army and Marine Corps. The military services have routinely poured money into recruiting and retention bonuses over the years. But the totals spiked as Pentagon leaders tried to reverse falling enlistment numbers, particularly as Covid-19 restrictions locked down public events, fairs and school visits that recruiters relied on to meet with young people.
13. OPEC+ Expected To Open Taps More Despite Price Slump - AFP
Despite oil trading low at $60, OPEC+ this week is expected to continue to further open the taps.
This follows pressure from President Donald Trump and group leader Saudi Arabia's quest to penalise allies that breach the cartel's quotas. In past months, Saudi Arabia, Russia and six other OPEC+ members have surprised markets by announcing a sharp increase in oil production for May and June despite the low prices.
14. Not Just Apple, All Phone Makers Will Face Tariffs If Not Made In U.S. - TIPP Insights
President Donald Trump said that all major smartphone makers, not just Apple, will face a 25% tariff if they manufacture devices outside the United States. The tariffs are set to take effect by the end of June.
“Otherwise it wouldn’t be fair,” Trump said, confirming that companies like Samsung will be included in the policy. “If they build their plant here, there’s no tariff at all.”
15. North Korean Warship Tough To Salvage After Launch Failure, Analysts Say - RFA
According to a report from the Beyond Parallel project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, or CSIS, the ship “may ultimately prove to be a complete loss.”
The Washington-based think tank said the launch failure is “an embarrassment to (leader) Kim Jong Un and North Korea’s Korean People’s Navy,” and would disrupt Kim’s plans to turn the navy from a coastal defense force to a blue-water one, capable of “strategic offensive operations.”
16. North Korea Arrests 4th Official Over Failed Warship Launch - D.W.
The accident last Wednesday crushed parts of the bottom of the new 5,000-ton destroyer.
The official Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) reported Monday that a fourth person, Ri Hyong Son, the vice department director of the Munitions Industry Department of the Party Central Committee, had been detained. According to KCNA, he was "greatly responsible for the occurrence of the serious accident." He is the most senior official to be detained in connection with the incident.
17. Report Blames Processed Foods, Poor Lifestyles For Health Epidemic - UPI Health
A Trump administration report released, backed by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., said highly processed foods, exposure to chemicals and excessive use of prescription drugs are among the factors responsible for chronic child illnesses in the United States.
Kennedy has called the nation's kids "the sickest generation in American history." A recent report by the Journal of the American Medical Association shows that foods and drinks like soft drinks, fast food chicken nuggets and highly processed packaged snacks comprise up to 70% of calories consumed by children and adolescents.
