This commentary, written by Shang-Jin Wei, a U.S.-based economist and former Chief Economist of the Asian Development Bank, examines how China might respond to President Trump’s tariff strategy. While the author writes from a global economic perspective, his piece sheds light on the strategic challenges facing China and the broader consequences of U.S. trade policy. We share it to help our readers understand the evolving dynamics of the U.S.-China relationship from multiple vantage points.
By Shang-Jin Wei - Project Syndicate | April 17, 2025
After eschewing tit-for-tat retaliatory measures against the United States during previous trade skirmishes, China is now responding in kind to the second Trump administration's tariffs. But while such a strategy makes sense, Chinese leaders also need to be thinking about off-ramps.
NEW YORK – China has taken a tough stance against US President Donald Trump, matching the last two rounds of US tariffs with tariffs of its own. The US tariff on goods from China is now 145%, while China’s is 125%. Why does China take such a position, and are there any off-ramps that would allow it to mitigate the costs of a prolonged trade war?
There are three plausible reasons why China has responded this way so far. First, Chinese leaders may believe that negotiation at this stage will not produce a satisfactory outcome. They regard the US approach as akin to a kidnapper: any concession could just invite more hostage taking. After all, China already abstained from responding in kind to two earlier rounds of incremental (10%) US tariffs, on February 1 and March 3, and that did not prevent Trump from adding another 34% levy on April 2.
The Chinese can see that Mexico and Canada are also being hit with new US tariffs, even though they agreed to Trump’s first-term demand to renegotiate the North American Free Trade Agreement. Similarly, following the first Trump administration’s tariffs on China in March 2018, the Chinese agreed to purchase more from the US, only to be met by even higher tariffs on a wider range of goods. Although they acceded to the unfavorable terms of the so-called Phase One Agreement in December 2019, the US retained 20% tariffs on Chinese goods.
The Chinese also consider it unfair for the US to refuse to sell them goods that they really want – such as advanced semiconductors and other technology-intensive products – while compelling them to buy more of the goods (soybeans) that they could obtain at a better price elsewhere. Is it any surprise that they would try a different strategy this time?
A second reason concerns “face” (as in “saving face”), which is important in Chinese culture. The Chinese may suspect that Trump looks down on foreign leaders who come to beg for lower tariffs. After all, he recently boasted that foreign governments were “kissing my ass.” At the same time, Trump is known to admire foreign leaders who exhibit toughness.
US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent wants to persuade the Chinese with the following logic: You should capitulate, as you are in a weaker position than the US, because the US can tariff more of its goods than vice versa. But this argument may have backfired, by reminding Chinese of the British position during the 1839-42 Opium war. The message then was: Our guns have a much longer range than yours, so why don’t you just capitulate and buy our opium?
Finally, the Chinese may worry about an unfavorable spillover effect from making concessions to the US. Since the high US tariffs could cause Chinese producers to divert some of their exports to other markets, many other countries are already considering their own additional tariffs on Chinese goods. A tough response to the US thus could function as a deterrent against such moves.
China is hoping that the turmoil in US financial markets will persuade Trump to change course. But its strategy could also trigger further US escalation. The bipartisan anti-China sentiment in Washington may be strong enough to allow the administration to stay the course, even if it proves painful to US households and firms. Moreover, losing access to the US market may add pressure to an already weakening Chinese economy.
So, are there off-ramps in this game of chicken? One option is for China to follow the Europeans in offering zero tariffs on US goods, as well as committing to policy reforms to reduce other market-distorting barriers if the US does the same. China could even propose a third-party monitoring mechanism – such as a panel of experts appointed by other World Trade Organization members – to ensure compliance.
A second option is to reinforce trading relations with other countries as leverage. Since many are concerned about Chinese export diversion from the US market, China could promise an import diversion: goods that it used to buy from US producers can now come from other countries. China is already the world’s second-largest importing country, and it could well claim first place if the US follows through with its “reciprocal” tariffs on the rest of the world. Thus, any country that introduces higher export barriers against China could risk losing a crucial export market.
China can also reduce its trade barriers on goods from other countries, as it did during the first Trump administration, and it could do a better job of advertising its International Import Expo. While most countries have export-promotion agencies, China may be unique in having a major state-sponsored exhibition devoted to imports. In the current context, the expo could promote more imports from countries that refrain from erecting new barriers.
Third, to reduce its trade surplus, China needs to find more effective ways to boost domestic consumption. A fundamental reorientation of its saving-consumption balance would require structural reforms to its social safety net, financial system, and gender balance, implying a multiyear process. While China could pursue macroeconomic stimulus in the short run, recent efforts have had only mixed results. What China really needs is much more aggressive monetary easing combined with fiscal measures that include temporary sales-tax cuts and consumption subsidies.
There is a very small chance that the US would accept an offer of zero-for-zero tariffs, at least for now. But a combination of trade reform, macroeconomic stimulus, and other structural measures to boost consumption and reduce net exports should be on the table anyway. Such an approach would be good for both China and the world economy, regardless of what the US does.
Shang-Jin Wei, a former chief economist at the Asian Development Bank, is Professor of Finance and Economics at Columbia Business School and Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs.
Copyright Project Syndicate
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. France's Macron Hosts Rubio And Witkoff At Élysée To Talk Ukraine - TIPP Insights
French President Emmanuel Macron welcomed U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff to the Élysée Palace today.
Joined by French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot, it is said to be a high-stakes diplomatic effort to advance a ceasefire in Ukraine. Before the meeting, Macron spoke with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, underscoring France’s continued coordination with Kyiv.
2. Zelensky Urges US And Europe To Pressure Russia To End War - BBC
The talks, hosted by French President Emmanuel Macron, formed the highest level of transatlantic engagement about the war since February.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky urged those at the meeting to put "pressure" on Russia to agree to a ceasefire, as "Russia uses every day and every night to kill".
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov dismissed the talks, claiming European leaders were focused on "continuing the war".
3. Russia Says Certain Countries Trying To ‘Derail’ Its Talks With U.S. - AFP
Kirill Dmitriev, Russia’s top economic negotiator, said that certain countries were trying to “derail” Moscow’s talks with the United States, as the two sides work towards normalizing ties.
“There are a lot of people, structures, countries trying to disrupt our dialogue with the United States. There is a very active propaganda against Russia going on in the United States in various mass media,” Kirill Dmitriev, who is also the head of Russia’s sovereign wealth fund, told reporters.
4. North Korean Troops May Enter Ukraine Soon, Kyiv Warns - RFA
North Korean forces deployed in Russia’s Kursk region may soon be sent into annexed regions of Ukraine that remain fiercely contested by Russian and Ukrainian forces, according to Andrei Kovalenko, head of the National Security Service’s Center for Countering Disinformation.
As many as 12,000 North Korean soldiers are in Russia, according to Ukraine and the U.S., to fight Ukrainian forces who occupied parts of Russia’s Kursk region in an August counter offensive.
5. Russia’s Supreme Court Removes Taliban From List Of Banned Organizations - Reuters
Russia’s supreme court has suspended the country’s ban on the Taliban in response to a request to do so by the prosecutor general, RIA news agency reported.
The move paves the way for the removal of the Taliban, which has ruled Afghanistan since 2021, from Russia’s list of terrorist organizations.
6. India Offers Cheap Loans For Arms, Targeting Russia's Traditional Customers - Reuters
The world's second-largest importer of weapons is expanding the ability of the state-owned Export-Import Bank (EXIM) to offer long-term, low-cost loans to clients, including those whose political or credit risk profiles may limit their access to conventional financing, according to Indian officials and industry sources.
New Delhi will also sharply increase the number of defense attachés in its foreign missions as part of a new program that will see the government directly negotiate some arms deals, four Indian officials said. India is particularly targeting governments which have long relied on Russia for arms, two of the people said.
7. China Leads World In Quality Of EV Patents, Says Think Tank - Nikkei Asia
According to a Tokyo-based think tank, Chinese car and battery makers are outpacing their Japanese and U.S. rivals in the quality of their electric vehicle-related patents, opening up opportunities for them to license their technology in response to the U.S. tariff threat.
Chinese companies, such as Contemporary Amperex Technology Co., Ltd. (CATL) and BYD, hold relatively few patents, according to Mitsui & Co. Global Strategic Studies Institute (MGSSI), the Japanese conglomerate's in-house think tank. However, they score highly on technological influence, as measured by number of citations and remaining life until expiry.
8. TSMC Says It Will Build 'Independent' Chip Hub In U.S - Nikkei Asia
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. plans to make 30% of the world's most cutting-edge semiconductors in Arizona to help the U.S. build an "independent" chip cluster. However, it said it is not in talks to form joint ventures or share technology with other chipmakers.
TSMC Chairman and CEO C.C. Wei said his company "is not engaged in any discussion with other companies regarding any joint venture, technology licensing or technology transfer and sharing," addressing market concerns over a rumored partnership with Intel to boost the U.S. chipmaker's output. TSMC is navigating headwinds from rising U.S. tariffs and tighter controls on AI chip exports.
9. Iran-U.S. Nuclear Talks Enter "Crucial" Stage, Says UN Watchdog - TIPP Insights
Negotiations between Iran and the United States over Tehran’s nuclear program are at a “very crucial” stage, according to Rafael Grossi, head of the UN’s International Atomic Energy Agency.
The two countries are set to meet in Rome on Saturday for a new round of talks, following initial discussions in Oman last weekend.
10. Israeli Opposition Leader Says Israel Must Strike Iran’s Nuclear Facilities - Al Arabiya
Israeli opposition leader Benny Gantz said Israel must strike Iran to prevent it from reaching nuclear capabilities after reports emerged that President Trump blocked a planned Israeli attack on Iranian nuclear sites to continue ongoing negotiations between U.S. and Iran.
Gantz, who leads Israel’s National Unity party, said Israel “must and can strike Iran.” “The Iranian Regime are experts at stalling,” he said Thursday in a post on X. “The State of Israel must, and can remove the prospect of Iranian nuclear capabilities.”
11. U.S. To Reduce Military Footprint In Syria, Officials Say - Al Arabiya
In December, the Pentagon revealed that there were around 2,000 U.S. troops in Syria, about 1,100 more than it had previously disclosed. At the time, the Biden administration said the fluctuation in the number of troops was in part due to the fall of the Assad regime.
The new plans are expected to be announced in the coming days, and they will reduce the total number of troops to around 1,000. Al Arabiya English understands that the number of U.S. military bases in Syria will also be reduced.
12. EU Looks To Tighten Visa Rules: 61 Countries Face Visa-Free Travel Overhaul - RFE/RL
The European Commission initiated the proposal to list more reasons for suspending visa-free travel in 2023, and the Council of the EU—which represents the 27 member states—already adopted its position on the matter a year ago.
The bloc is becoming much more hard-nosed about visa liberalization, reflecting a broader shift: first, to combat any form of illegal migration into the EU; and second, to potentially use visa policy as a political tool to pressure third countries.
13. European Central Bank Cuts Interest Rates, Warns Of 'Deteriorated' Growth Outlook On Trade Tensions - CNBC
The European Central Bank made yet another 25-basis-point interest rate cut on Thursday as global tariff turmoil has created widespread uncertainty and spurred fears about the euro zone’s economic growth.
The cut takes the ECB’s deposit facility rate, its key rate, to 2.25%. At its highs in mid-2023 it had been at 4%.
14. Scientists Find 'Strongest Evidence Yet' Of Life On Distant Planet - BBC
A Cambridge team studying the atmosphere of a planet called K2-18b has detected signs of molecules which on Earth are only produced by simple organisms.
This is the second, and more promising, time chemicals associated with life have been detected in the planet's atmosphere by Nasa's James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). But the team and independent astronomers stress that more data is needed to confirm these results.
15. North Korea Warns Of 'Overwhelming Deterrence' After U.S.-South Korea Air Drills - UPI
North Korea’s warning against the United States came following Washington's deployment of B-1B strategic bombers to the Korean Peninsula for a joint air exercise with South Korea this week.
The United States sent a pair of B-1B strategic bombers to participate in joint drills on Tuesday, which was a holiday in North Korea marking the birthday of founder Kim Il Sung.
16. EU Reports Record Number Of Warnings On Harmful Products - D.W.
According to a report released, the European Commission received 4,137 warnings about harmful products from national authorities in 2024.
The alerts were issued via "Safety Gate," which is a system allowing authorities to report dangerous non-food products. Topping the list were cosmetic products that contained harmful chemicals like the fragrance BMHCA, which has been banned in the EU since 2022.
17. Google Sued In Britain For Alleged Monopolization Of Advertising - UPI
A press release from the Geradin Partners law firm alleged that Google "has used its dominant position to exclude actual and potential competitors from the general search and search advertising markets, allowing Google to charge supracompetitive ad prices."
The class action suit filing purports that Google, owned by the U.S. company Alphabet, contracted phone makers to pre-install Google and the Chrome browser on iPhones and Android devices.
18. Gold Hits New Record Over U.S.-China Trade War Fears - BBC
Spot gold touched $3,357.40 per ounce on Wednesday, before dipping from its peak. It has risen by around a third since the start of the year.
The rise follows comments by the head of U.S. central bank who said President Donald Trump's tariff policies are likely to mean slower growth, higher prices and unemployment risks. The precious metal is viewed as a safer asset for investors during times of economic uncertainty.
19. These Countries' Stock Markets Are Racing Ahead Of The U.S. - IBD
Shares of ETFs connected with dozens of nations, including Poland, Spain, Germany and Brazil, are all surging ahead of the U.S.-focused S&P 500.
Many of these countries are expected to benefit indirectly from the Trump administration's on-again-off-again approach to tariffs. IShares MSCI Poland ETF (EPOL) has returned 32.2% this year. IShares MSCI Spain ETF (EWP) is up 24.6% and iShares MSCI Germany ETF (EWG) is up 17.2%, says Morningstar Direct. All these are blowing away the nearly 8% loss, including dividends, by the U.S.-centric S&P 500.
20. Bitcoin Miners In U.S. Fear Wipeout As 36% Tariffs Threaten To ‘destroy’ Thriving Industry - Fortune
When China cracked down on the crypto industry in 2021, many Bitcoin miners set up shop in the U.S. instead. The move paid off as a mix of cheap energy and deep capital markets saw the U.S. become the world’s leader in Bitcoin production.
In April, all of that changed. That’s because, even as the U.S. took the lead in production, American miners continued to rely heavily on machines from Asia—machines that are now subject to hefty tariffs as high as 36% as Trump aims to choke off overseas imports.
21. Heavy Marijuana Use May Raise Dementia Risk Within Five Years - HealthDay News
Middle-aged folks and seniors whose weed use lands them in the hospital are at higher risk for developing dementia within a matter of years, a new study says.
An ER visit or hospitalization due to cannabis use is associated with a 72% increased risk of a dementia diagnosis within five years compared to the general population, researchers reported in JAMA Neurology. These folks also have a 23% increased risk of dementia within five years compared to people receiving hospital care for any other reason, researchers added.
